Gas Fireplace or Electric Fireplace: A quick comparison guide

November 20, 2023

When it comes to choosing between a gas or electric fireplace in Canada, it's essential to consider various factors to make the right decision for your home. In this comparison guide, we'll help you weigh the options and find the best fit for the specific needs of your home.

Gas Fireplace or Electric Fireplace in Canada

Heat Output and Efficiency

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
Higher BTUs (20, 000 to 40, 000) Ideal for heating larger areas Real flames and consistent heat	Lower BTU (3,000 - 10,000) Efficient energy conservation Best for small spaces and rooms

Best fireplace for heat output and efficiency: Gas Fireplace

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Installation and Setup

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
More complex installation Potentially higher installation costs Requires gas line installation and possible chimney construction	Easier DIY installation Various lighting and colour options available in a single unit No need for venting or chimney

Best fireplace for installation and setup: Electric Fireplace

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Maintenance and Safety

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
Requires annual servicing Carbon monoxide detectors recommended	Little to no maintenance Lower fire risk Check power source and cords periodically

Best fireplace for maintenance and safety: Electric Fireplaces

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Appearance and Ambiance

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
Realistic flames and ambiance that can never be perfectly imitated Customizable flame height Various trims, log sets, and finishes	Versatile designs and styles Customizable heat and light LED lights for mood setting

Best for appearances, ambiance and statement: Gas Fireplace

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Lifespan

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
Lifespan of about 20 to 25 years Occasional part replacements and annual servicing	Lifespan of about 10 to 20 years Minimal servicing More difficult to replace single parts when broken

Best fireplace for their lifespan: Gas Fireplace

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Total Costs

Gas Fireplace	Electric Fireplace
Installation costs may be higher Operating costs depends on local gas prices (generally lower than electricity in Canada) and usage	Lower installation costs, generally Operating costs depends on local electricity prices (generally higher than gas in Canada) and usage

Best fireplace for total costs: Electric Fireplace

Click here for a more comprehensive comparison.

Finding the best fireplace for your Canadian home

Choose a Gas Fireplace If:	Choose an Electric Fireplace If:
You seek a long-term consistent heat source for your home You want real flames and reliable heat year-round	You prefer a simple installation and minimal upkeep costs You're looking for a quick heating solution for a smaller room

At the end of the day, your choice between a gas fireplace or electric fireplace depends on your specific needs and preferences. Consider factors such as heat output, installation, maintenance, appearance, costs, and lifespan to make the right decisions for your home.

Barbecues Galore has the best selection of barbecues, grilling accessories, patio furniture, outdoor heating supplies, and fireplaces in Canada. We pride ourselves on providing you with the best backyard experiences and home comfort possible. With locations in Calgary and the GTA, you can visit us in store or shop online. North Calgary Store: (403) 250-1558 | South Calgary Store: (403) 258-4440 | Burlington Store: (905) 639-5952 | Oakville Store: (905) 844-3224 | Etobicoke Store: (416) 546-3266

Back to blog